Skip to content
Astera Technology

Remove a dominated scope option before choosing tradeoffs

Compare effort and supplied benefit points without inventing a weighted score.

Plan from the supplied facts

The fictional owner supplies benefit points solely for this exercise. Less effort and more points are preferred. An option is dominated if another needs no more effort and gives no fewer points, with at least one strict improvement. A and C below remain a real tradeoff.

Editable original planning example
OptionEffort hBenefit pointsPosition
A66Not dominated
B86Dominated by A and C
C79Not dominated
Download editable CSV ↓

Work through the choice

A beats B on effort at the same points. C also beats B on both measures. A is cheaper than C, but C has more points, so neither dominates the other.

Can dominance alone select A over C?

Show the worked answer

No. It can remove B, but choosing A versus C needs a stated tradeoff preference or effort constraint.

Material to use in your plan

Use effort and benefit in separate columns, marking the option that dominates each removed row. Retain the remaining frontier without pretending that one measure automatically outweighs the other.

Related resources