Skip to content
Astera Technology

Menu modifier or stocked product variant?

Classify options by what changes in stock, preparation and price.

Download complete case notes and answer keys ↓

Compare the operating models

A fictional red mug is a stocked SKU. Less ice changes preparation only. Extra egg changes an ingredient and has a supplied charge. Treating all three as free text loses stock meaning; treating them all as finished variants creates unnecessary products.

Filled decision worksheet
Business requirementStock variantPreparation modifier
Red mugSelect actual SKUNote cannot replace stock choice
Less iceNo distinct finished stock hereInstruction on drink line
Extra eggNot a separate prepared dish by defaultIngredient effect plus supplied charge
Download editable CSV ↓

Work through the chosen model

Modifier definitions retain allowed parent items, preparation text, supplied charge and ingredient effect where the business models it. The sale line retains selected modifiers. A stocked variant instead points to the selected SKU and its own quantity.

  1. Select product and relevant options
  2. Record stock or preparation effects
  3. Send matching pick/preparation detail

Modifiers keep menus manageable but need clear effects. Variants support distinct stock; a colour or size label alone does not tell you which model is correct.

One red mug reduces red-mug stock by one. One less-ice drink retains a preparation instruction. One extra-egg noodle includes one extra egg under the supplied recipe policy.

When the other model fits

Bottled red and white drinks are preproduced and independently stocked. Still use only a colour modifier?

Show the worked answer

No. Choose the actual stocked product/variant.

Related resources